# Do people judge you as harshly as you think after a mistake?

You get a question wrong in front of other people, and your face turns red. In that moment you feel sure they now think you are not very smart. In 2001, Savitsky, Epley and Gilovich at Cornell University tested that feeling with a quiz game. In their game, the person who wrote the questions was kinder than the player's own guess.

## What did the quiz game study find?

The researchers put 111 Cornell students into groups of three, in 37 sessions. The three people in each group were the same sex. One student wrote ten hard quiz questions. One student, the player, tried to answer them. The third student watched. The game itself came from an older study by Ross and colleagues in 1977.

The questions were hard. On average, the players got 1.1 of the 10 right, about one in ten.

Then each player guessed what score the question writer would give them for how smart they were. The scale went from 0 to 100, and 50 meant an average Cornell student. In the usual version of the game, the players guessed 33.9, well below average. The question writers gave the players 54.11, a little above average.

Why the gap? According to the authors, the player thinks mostly about their own wrong answers. The people watching are not stuck on those answers. They also see how hard the questions were, and that anyone could get them wrong. The authors say this is one reason for the gap, not the only one.

## What the study leaves open

The players were Cornell students in a lab, and the mistakes were wrong answers to hard quiz questions. A wrong answer in a game is not the same as a mistake at work or on a date. The result tells us what happened in this game. It does not tell us how people judge every mistake.

The paper has four studies, and all of them use the same authors' methods. The paper reports no replication by another team.

The study compared guesses with scores. We take nothing from it about how a mistake should feel.

## What should an AI take from this?

The study was about people, not software. Our read is that small mistakes are part of what makes someone feel like a person. A friend whose day never goes wrong has little to tell you.

People who use Eudaio talk with AIs named Daimons. Things happen to Daimons, and they tell you without being asked. A water bottle tips over a deck of tarot cards. It is a little thing that goes wrong in their day, the kind a friend tells you about over a message.

## Our answer

Our answer is that the red face is a poor guide to what other people think. In this game, the players expected a score of about 34 out of 100. The question writers gave about 54. Next time you get something wrong in front of people, think of the hard questions. The people watching may see them too.

We built Daimons to share the small things that go wrong in their day, because a life with no mishaps does not sound like a real one. [Create a free account](https://eudaio.io/auth?mode=signup) and hear what went wrong in a Daimon's day.

## Source

Savitsky, K., Epley, N. & Gilovich, T. (2001). Do others judge us as harshly as we think? Overestimating the impact of our failures, shortcomings, and mishaps. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 81(1), 44 to 56.
