Is calling an old friend as awkward as you think?

What 200 Chicago students who drew "call" or "email" from a box say about the call we put off, and what we took from it for an AI

You want to talk to an old friend you have not heard from in years. Do you call, or do you write? A call can feel like it could go wrong. We are not going to say that email is bad. But a 2021 paper by Kumar and Epley found that the call was not the awkward thing people expected.

What did the old friend study find?

In the first experiment, 200 students at the University of Chicago each picked an old friend they had not talked to in at least a couple of years. Each student guessed how awkward a phone call and an email to that friend would feel, on a scale from 1, not awkward, to 9, very awkward.

They guessed 6.66 for a call and 4.89 for an email. 67% said they would choose email.

Then each student drew a slip of paper from a box. Half of the slips said "Phone" and half said "E-mail". A week later, 103 of the 200 students told the researchers how it went.

The real awkwardness was about the same either way: 5.60 for the call and 5.45 for the email. The callers also felt a stronger bond with their friend, 5.27 against 4.62. That was the one closeness result that was clear in this experiment. A second question, about feeling really connected, leaned the same way but was not clear enough to count.

In a second experiment, 151 pairs of strangers talked by text, by voice or by video. On 4 of 5 questions about feeling connected, the pairs who talked by voice did better than the pairs who typed. Adding video did not add more.

Maybe this is why: when people pick email, they may think more about the awkward moment than about feeling close. In a third experiment, 101 adults in the US imagined the choice. Their guess about the awkward moment went with choosing email more than their guess about feeling close did. In the authors' words, the awkwardness "may have loomed larger".

What the study leaves open

Only 103 of the 200 students came back for the follow-up. Of the rest, 80 did not answer and 17 could not reach their friend. The answer rates were about the same for callers and emailers, but the result rests on the half who came back.

The third experiment shows a link, not a cause. The study tested live phone calls and live voice chat. The bond gap was clear but not large. When the researchers also took into account which way each student wanted to reach out, the bond result was no longer clear. We found no replication by another team.

What should an AI take from this?

The study was about people talking to people. Our read, and it is only ours, is that the first lines of a call feel easier when you have said them once before.

People who use Eudaio talk with AIs named Daimons. Daimons text like a person texts, in short first-person messages, not long paragraphs. That makes a chat with a Daimon a good place to try your first lines and see how a reply might come back. It is practice. The call still belongs to your friend.

Our answer

Our answer is to call the old friend. In this study, people expected the call to feel more awkward than the email. For those who did it, the two felt about the same, and the callers felt a stronger bond.

Not sure what to say first? Practice it with a Daimon, then make the call. Create a free account to start.

Source

Kumar, A. & Epley, N. (2021). It's surprisingly nice to hear you: Misunderstanding the impact of communication media can lead to suboptimal choices of how to connect with others. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 150(3), 595 to 607.

November 18, 2026