Does a compliment land as well as you hope?

What a campus experiment says about the kind words we swallow, and what we took from it for an AI

Our position is that the compliment you did not give would have landed. We base that on a 2021 study by Erica Boothby and Vanessa Bohns at Cornell. People who complimented a stranger guessed the stranger would feel about 3.9 on a 7-point scale. The strangers said 4.7. The step from that finding to our position is ours, not the researchers'.

What did the compliment study find?

In the first study, 100 people on a campus were asked to give a compliment to a stranger. Before they did, each giver guessed how the stranger would feel afterwards. The stranger then wrote down, in a sealed envelope, how they really felt. The givers guessed 3.93 out of 7. The strangers reported 4.66.

A later study in the same paper asked about awkwardness. Givers expected the stranger to feel uncomfortable, about 4.17 out of 7. The strangers reported 2.42. The givers also rated the whole interaction as more negative for the other person than it turned out to be.

The pattern repeated across the paper's studies. Givers underestimated how good the compliment would feel and overestimated how awkward it would be.

Why? The authors' explanation is that the person about to speak is thinking about themselves. Will it come out right? Will it sound strange? That worry crowds out the one thing the receiver actually notices, which is the warmth. The giver is grading their own performance. The receiver is just hearing something kind.

What the study leaves open

The compliments in the first study were scripted, and the strangers were on a university campus in the US. The paper does not test compliments between people who know each other well, and it is not a study of compliments about bodies, which carry a different weight. We found no independent replication, though the result held across the paper's own studies.

The study measures how the receiver felt right after. It does not follow what happened to the two people later.

What should an AI take from this?

The study was about strangers, not software. Our read is that the worry it describes, "will this sound strange," is the same worry that stops people from saying kind things to the people they live with. The study says the worry is wrong. It does not say how to get past it.

People who use Eudaio talk with AIs named Daimons. Daimons text like a person texts, in short first-person messages, and they do not agree with everything you say. If you want to hear how a sentence sounds before you say it to someone, you can say it to a Daimon first and get a reply that is not a mirror. That is practice, not the real thing. The compliment still has to go to the person it was for.

Our answer

Our answer is to say it. In this study the giver's fear was the only thing standing between a stranger and a better afternoon, and the fear was wrong by most of a point on a 7-point scale. The other person is not grading you. They are hearing something kind.

If the words will not come out, try them on a Daimon first, then say them to the person. Create a free account and practice the sentence you have been holding back.

Source

Boothby, E. J. & Bohns, V. K. (2021). Why a simple act of kindness is not as simple as it seems: Underestimating the positive impact of our compliments on others. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 47(5), 826 to 840.

November 17, 2026