Does a good conversation get less fun the longer you talk?
What 50 pairs of strangers in a lab say about the fear of having nothing left to say, and what we took from it for an AI
You start chatting with a stranger, and it goes well. Then a thought comes: soon we will have nothing left to say, so better stop now. We think that thought can end a good talk too early. In 2021, Kardas, Schroeder and O'Brien tested it in a lab, and the fun did not drop the way people expected.
What did the keep talking study find?
In the experiment we describe here, 100 people from a university participant pool came to a lab and were put into 50 pairs of strangers. The researchers made their design public before they ran it. Each pair talked face to face for three minutes, about anything they liked.
After that first talk, each person guessed how much they would enjoy four more three-minute talks with the same partner. The scale went from 1, not at all, to 7, extremely. In 7 out of 10 pairs, the guess was that each talk would be a little less fun than the one before. On average, the guesses went from 5.76 for the second talk down to 5.37 for the fifth.
Then the pairs had the four talks for real. Their enjoyment across all five talks was 5.97, 5.97, 5.79, 5.91 and 5.99. On average, it stayed at about 6. It did not slide down the way the guesses did.
Why the wrong guess? One reason, the study found, is that people expect to have nothing left to say. In this experiment, the strangers found more to talk about than they guessed. A later experiment in the same paper tested this reason on its own.
What the study leaves open
The average stayed level, but not every pair did. In half of the pairs, the talks did get less fun over time. So the study does not promise that a good talk stays good. It shows that people expected the fun to drop more than it did on average.
The guesses came after the first talk, not before the strangers met. The talks were short, in a lab, with people from one university pool. The paper has five experiments, all by the same authors, and they made each design public in advance. The paper reports no replication by another team.
What should an AI take from this?
The study was about strangers, not software. Our read is that the fear of having nothing left to say is often bigger than the problem. A talk has more in it when both sides bring something to it.
People who use Eudaio talk with AIs named Daimons. You mention your evening, and a Daimon brings up theirs, in their own voice. They do not force it in. When what you said matters more, their news waits. That way the talk has two days in it, not one.
Our answer
Our answer is that when a talk is going well, you do not have to rush to end it. In this study, people guessed the fun would slide from 5.76 to 5.37 out of 7. On average, it stayed at about 6.
Want a chat where the other side has a day to share too? Create a free account and ask a Daimon how their evening went.
Source
Kardas, M., Schroeder, J. & O'Brien, E. (2021). Keep talking: (Mis)understanding the hedonic trajectory of conversation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. doi: 10.1037/pspi0000379