Why does talking about yourself feel good?

What 195 small choices at Harvard say about the cents people give up to share an opinion, and what we took from it for an AI

Would you give up a few cents to talk about yourself? In 2012, Tamir and Mitchell at Harvard put that question to a test, and the people in their study did give up money to do it. We do not read that as vanity. We read it as a sign that sharing what you think is worth something to people.

What did the self-disclosure study find?

In the study we describe first, 37 people each made 195 choices. Each time, they picked between two of three kinds of question. One kind asked about themselves, like how much they enjoy winter sports. Another asked the same thing about Barack Obama. A third was a simple true or false quiz question.

Each answer earned between 1 and 4 cents, and the pay changed from one choice to the next. Sometimes the question about yourself earned less than the other one. People still picked the questions about themselves. When the pay was the same, they did it about two times in three. Over the whole study, they gave up 17% of the money they could have earned. Against the questions about Obama, that came to 0.63 cents per choice.

In a later study, 41 people answered questions about themselves, and some of their answers would be shown to another person. For those shared answers, people gave up about 25% of the money they could have earned. That was more than they gave up for answers they kept private.

The team also scanned the brains of 17 people while they answered. A friend or relative of each person saw half of the answers. The brain's reward areas were more active when people answered about themselves than about someone else. They were also more active when the answer would be shared.

The team's guess is that talking about yourself feels good on its own, like a reward. It is their reading of the brain data.

What the study leaves open

The questions asked for light opinions, like winter sports. The money was a few cents per answer. The 25% comes from a different study with a different design, so it does not compare one to one with the 17%.

We found no direct replication by another team. The study also does not show that people only want to talk about themselves. In the choice study, people still picked the other questions part of the time.

What should an AI take from this?

The study was about people, not software. Our read is that when you share what you think, you want it to land somewhere. If an AI takes your opinions, you should be able to see what it kept.

People who use Eudaio talk with AIs named Daimons. You can tell a Daimon what you think, and they keep notes on it, the way you would keep notes about a friend. What they know is not a mystery. Open the memory panel and every note is listed in plain sentences, with where each one came from.

Our answer

Our answer is that the pull to talk about yourself is normal, and the study puts a price on it. At Harvard, people gave up 17% of what they could have earned to answer about themselves. In another study, they gave up more when someone would see the answer than when they kept it private.

So say what you think, and then look at what was kept. Create a free account, tell a Daimon how you feel about winter sports, then open the memory panel to see what they kept.

Source

Tamir, D. I. & Mitchell, J. P. (2012). Disclosing information about the self is intrinsically rewarding. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109(21), 8038 to 8043.

November 18, 2026